The Real Value of Google Reviews (and How to Get More of Them)
Why Google Reviews Matter
Think of reviews as word-of-mouth marketing’s cooler, scalable cousin. They influence buying decisions, send trust signals to search engines, and make it easier for your ideal customer to find and choose you.
Here’s what Google Reviews actually do:
| Benefit | Why It Matters |
|---|---|
| Improve your local SEO | Reviews are a key ranking factor in local search results and the “map pack.” More high-quality reviews = better visibility when someone searches for services near them. |
| Build social proof | Potential customers don’t just want to hear from you, they want to hear from people who’ve worked with you. Real reviews validate your claims. |
| Increase click-through rates | Star ratings show up in search results, and studies show users are more likely to click businesses with higher ratings and more reviews. |
| Provide free market research | Reviews highlight what customers love (and what they don’t). That’s gold for improving your services and messaging. |
| Boost trust (even when not perfect) | A few four-stars or thoughtful critiques can actually increase believability. No one trusts 300 reviews with all 5 stars and no detail. |
Yes, You Should Prioritize Reviews—Especially if You’re a Local Business or Nonprofit
If you’re a nonprofit, local business, or women- or BIPOC-owned brand, here’s the truth: your audience wants to support you. Google Reviews help them find you.
For purpose-driven orgs, reviews aren’t about clout, they’re about community. They build credibility with people who share your values. They help donors, members, and customers say “yes” faster because someone like them already did.
Even if you’re not trying to be the biggest name in your industry, you still deserve visibility. And reviews are one of the easiest (and most affordable) ways to earn it.
Plus, for organizations historically excluded from traditional marketing channels or networks, Google Reviews can help level the playing field. They amplify word-of-mouth, show proof of your impact, and help build trust, without needing a huge budget.
So if you’ve been putting off asking because you don’t want to “bother” people, think of it this way: you’re giving your biggest supporters a way to pay it forward.
Psychology 101: Why 4.6 Stars Beats a Perfect 5.0
Let’s bust a myth while we’re here.
You do not need a perfect score.
In fact, research shows that consumers trust ratings between 4.2 and 4.8 more than a flat 5.0. A slightly imperfect score suggests the reviews are real, not curated or fake.
According to a PowerReviews study:
82% of shoppers seek out negative reviews to better understand potential drawbacks
60% say they’re more likely to trust a brand with a mix of positive and negative reviews
A negative review can actually increase conversions if the response is thoughtful and shows accountability
So if you’ve been worried that asking for reviews could open the floodgates to nitpicking, know this: transparency > perfection.
How to Ask for Google Reviews (Without It Feeling Awkward)
Now to the part people stress over most: the ask.
No one wants to feel like they’re begging. But asking for a review doesn’t have to be weird, especially when it’s rooted in real gratitude and timing.
Here’s how to approach it:
When to Ask
After a successful service, project, or transaction
When a client sends a “thank you” email
At the close of an event or campaign
When you reach a milestone together
After positive feedback during a check-in or meeting
Timing is everything. Ask when the experience is fresh, and emotions are positive.
How to Ask
Customize the language to fit your brand voice, but keep it human. Here are some examples:
Casual & Warm
"It means the world to us when people share their experience. If you have a minute, would you mind leaving us a quick review on Google?"
Mission-Driven
"We grow through word-of-mouth, and reviews help more folks find our work. If you believe in what we’re building, we’d love your feedback here."
Client-Focused
"Your support helps others know they’re in good hands. Here’s a quick link if you’re open to sharing a few words: [Insert Review Link]"
Tips to Make It Easy
Use a shortened, direct review link (you can grab this from your Google Business Profile)
Include the ask in follow-up emails or text reminders
Add a simple CTA on your website or email signature
If you’re a nonprofit, tie the request back to impact or storytelling
Email/Message Scripts for Asking Clients
Here are some plug-and-play templates you can adjust based on context:
After Project Completion (Email)
Hi [Name],
We loved working with you on [Project/Service]. If you found the experience helpful, would you consider leaving us a quick Google review? It really helps more people find and trust our work.
Here’s the link: [Review Link]
Thanks so much!
For Nonprofits or Mission-Oriented Orgs
Hi [Name],
Thanks again for supporting [Campaign/Service]! Reviews help us reach more people and grow our impact. If you have a minute, we’d be grateful if you shared a few words about your experience: [Review Link]
Your voice helps us go further.
For Text/DM/Follow-Ups
Hey [Name]! Quick favor—would you mind leaving us a review here? [Link] It helps others find us and means a lot. Thanks!
What About Negative Reviews?
They’ll happen. And that’s okay.
Here’s how to handle them like a pro:
| Situation | Response Strategy |
|---|---|
| Legitimate Critique | Acknowledge it. Thank them. Offer to make it right or clarify what changed. |
| Misunderstanding | Stay calm. Clarify with facts (politely). Invite them to continue the conversation offline. |
| Troll/Spam | Report it to Google for removal if it violates policies. Don’t engage. |
Whatever the case, responding publicly shows that you care. Future customers are watching how you handle things.
Building a Review Strategy That Sticks
You don’t need to get 50 reviews overnight. A steady drip is more sustainable (and looks more natural to Google).
Build review collection into your workflow:
Add a review ask to post-purchase or post-service emails
Set reminders for your team to follow up
Consider light incentives (e.g., "leave a review, get a free sticker")
Celebrate team wins when positive reviews come in
Track progress
Use your Google Business dashboard to monitor:
Number of reviews
Average rating
Review keywords (to identify what people mention most)
That data can help you refine your services and your messaging.
What to Do Right Now If You’re Just Getting Started
If your Google Reviews are sitting at 3 or you haven’t asked in a year, don’t panic. Here’s your starter checklist:
Claim and verify your Google Business Profile
Add a direct link to your Google Reviews page
Make a list of happy clients/customers from the past 6–12 months
Send 5–10 personalized emails or messages this week
Start tracking responses and replies
Set a quarterly reminder to ask past or ongoing clients
If you’re a values-driven organization, remember: people want to support you!. You’re just helping them take the next step.
Final Takeaways
Google Reviews are not just a box to check—they’re a key part of how people find and choose your business. And getting more of them doesn’t require a huge campaign or a polished script. It just takes intention, consistency, and a little courage to ask.
At Avenue, we help purpose-driven brands show up clearly, credibly, and consistently online. If you want support building out your reputation strategy—from local SEO to full-funnel ads—we’re ready when you are.
Want even more marketing tips and insights that make a difference? Join our digital community:
Subscribe to our Conscious Marketer Newsletter
Listen to our Podcast The Conscious Marketer Podcast
Follow us on Instagram
Follow us on TikTok
