Combating Digital Bias: Why Engagement Rate Matters More Than Your Follower Count
If you've ever felt pressure to grow your follower count at all costs, you're not alone — but the reality is, it's not the number that matters most. Seeing that count climb feels validating. It looks good on paper. It gives the illusion of success.
But here’s the truth: Follower count is not a real measure of impact. It’s a surface-level number that tells you little about how your brand is actually resonating with people.
If you want to grow a loyal community, build brand trust, and turn casual scrollers into active supporters, there’s one metric that matters more than anything else: your engagement rate.
Why Follower Count Became a Vanity Metric
Follower counts started as one of the earliest public "success" signals on social media platforms. The bigger the number, the more credibility it seemed to carry — whether you were an influencer, a business, or a brand.
Unfortunately, that perception stuck. Over time, more people started buying followers, chasing quantity over quality, and treating follower growth as the ultimate goal — even when it didn’t lead to meaningful results.
Today, platforms themselves are moving away from prioritizing follower counts. Algorithms favor content that sparks real interaction. And brands are realizing that an audience that cares is far more valuable than an audience that’s just...there.
In short: Engagement is the new currency of digital success.
What Is Engagement Rate (and Why Should You Care)?
Engagement rate is the percentage of your audience that actively interacts with your content — through likes, shares, saves, comments, clicks, or other meaningful actions.
It’s a powerful metric because it tells you:
Are people connecting with what you’re posting?
Are they paying attention?
Are they motivated enough to engage?
Unlike follower count, engagement rate measures interest, relevance, and community-building — things that actually move the needle for your brand.
Why Engagement Rate > Follower Count
Let’s get specific. Here’s why focusing on engagement matters:
1. Real Connections Drive Business Results
You don't build loyal customers or advocates by having a big number next to your name. You build them through relationships. High engagement shows that your brand is cultivating genuine trust and interest — the kind that leads to actions like purchases, signups, and word-of-mouth referrals.
2. Algorithms Reward Engagement
On platforms like Instagram, LinkedIn, TikTok, and Facebook, posts that get higher engagement are pushed to more users — even beyond your followers.
The better your engagement, the more visible your content becomes.
It’s a compounding advantage.
A brand with 500 highly engaged followers can outperform a brand with 5,000 disengaged ones.
3. You Build Community, Not Just Audience
Followers are passive. Community members are active.
Strong engagement creates two-way conversations. It builds emotional investment. It transforms customers into champions — and champions into a movement.
In a noisy digital world, community wins.
What's Considered a Good Engagement Rate?
Engagement rates vary by platform, but here are general benchmarks to aim for:
| Platform | Strong Engagement Rate |
|---|---|
| 1%–5% | |
| 1%–2% | |
| 2%–5% | |
| TikTok | 4%–18% |
Smaller accounts tend to have higher engagement rates because their communities are often tighter and more personal. Don’t be discouraged if your numbers don't match those of mega-influencers. You’re building something more meaningful.
How to Calculate Your Engagement Rate
You don't need a fancy analytics platform to track your engagement rate — a simple formula will do the trick:
Engagement Rate = (Total Engagement/Total Followers) * 100
Total engagements = all likes, comments, saves, shares, clicks, etc. on a post
Total followers = how many followers you had when you posted
Example:
If a post got 75 likes, 20 comments, and 5 shares (100 total engagements) and you have 2,000 followers:
(100÷2000)×100=5%(100 \div 2000) \times 100 = 5\%(100÷2000)×100=5%
Your engagement rate would be 5% — which is fantastic.
Platforms like Instagram and LinkedIn often show these metrics automatically now, but calculating it yourself gives you the power to understand — and improve — your content over time.
Tip: Look at your average engagement rate over a month or quarter instead of focusing on one-off posts. It’s the trend that matters.
Common Myths About Followers and Engagement
Let’s bust a few outdated ideas that might be holding your brand back:
Myth 1: More followers automatically means more success.
→ Not if they’re not active. 10,000 silent followers won’t grow your business. 500 engaged ones might.
Myth 2: Engagement rate doesn’t matter if you post a lot.
→ Posting volume helps — but only if your audience cares about what you’re sharing. Engagement is the real measure of content quality.
Myth 3: You can "fix" engagement with more ads.
→ Paid reach can help, but if your organic engagement is low, it usually means your messaging needs tuning. Focus on connection first, amplification second.
How to Improve Your Engagement Rate
1. Invite action with every post.
Ask a question. Encourage shares. Use polls or interactive stickers. Every post should open the door to a two-way conversation.
2. Post when your audience is most active.
Timing matters. Check your platform insights to find your best posting windows and meet your audience when they're online and ready to engage.
3. Prioritize storytelling.
Stories connect. Instead of selling a product or service, tell the story behind it. Why does it matter? Who does it help? How does it change lives? Stories stick.
4. Make saving and sharing easy.
Create content people want to bookmark or pass along. Think tips, templates, infographics, mini-guides, or motivational quotes. Saveable = shareable = higher engagement.
5. Respond — thoughtfully.
Engagement is a two-way street. Acknowledge comments, thank users for shares, and jump into conversations when appropriate. Your community notices when you show up.
6. Track and learn.
Keep an eye on what posts are performing best and why. Use your data as a roadmap to double down on what’s working — and pivot away from what’s not.
Combating Digital Bias by Demystifying Digital Marketing
When we talk about combating digital bias, we’re talking about breaking down the barriers that have kept effective marketing strategies feeling out of reach for too many.
Historically, insider knowledge about digital success — how algorithms work, how to read analytics, how to build sustainable engagement — has been gatekept, favoring bigger brands, privileged groups, and those with deep pockets or industry connections.
At Avenue, we believe that access to good marketing education shouldn't be reserved for a select few.
By making concepts like engagement rates understandable, actionable, and accessible, we help level the playing field — giving small businesses, nonprofits, and purpose-driven brands the tools they need to thrive online.
Because real success isn’t about looking popular.
It’s about building real connections, driving real impact, and making sure everyone — not just the biggest voices in the room — gets a chance to be heard.
Engagement isn't just a metric. It’s a movement.
And every meaningful connection you build online is a step toward a more inclusive digital world.
Subscribe to our Conscious Marketer Newsletter
Listen to our Podcast The Conscious Marketer Podcast
Follow us on Instagram
Follow us on TikTok
